Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) as a possible cause of mania and insomnia

Multiple Chemical Sensitivity is an abnormal reactivity to common contaminants and common chemicals in the environment that adversely affect quality of life, also known as “Environmental Illness”.

By Dr Adrian Morris

Synonyms: Environmental Illness, Multiple Chemical Sensitivity, Idiopathic Environmental Illness, 20th Century Disease, Universal Allergy, Total Allergy Syndrome, Allergic Toxaemia.

Randolph hypothesised that the body was like “a barrel filling up with chemicals” until a critical point is reached after which it reacts to any further chemical exposure. With numerous household chemicals and everyday agents suspected in the aetiology, the label Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) was coined by Cullen in the 1980’s [1]. MCS enjoyed wide acceptance as a medical condition in the popular lay media, amongst alternative practitioners, and in those individuals with non-specific symptoms who self-diagnosed themselves with MCS.

Up to 16% of individuals report some form of “unusual sensitivity” to common everyday chemicals…

Up to 16% of individuals report some form of “unusual sensitivity” to common everyday chemicals (a phenomenon which is culturally restricted to North America and Europe).  This prompted the National Institute of Environmental Health in the USA to develop a consensus statement in 1999 [2].  The NIEH defined multiple chemical sensitivity as a “chronic recurring disease caused by a person’s inability to tolerate an environmental chemical or class of foreign chemicals” and proposed the preferred medical term Idiopathic Environmental Intolerance (IEI) with 6 diagnostic criteria (see figure 1).

Symptoms attributed to MCS/IEI are diffuse and include: recurrent headaches, sinus and nasal congestion, itchy eyes and throat, with abdominal symptoms such as nausea and vomiting, diarrhoea or constipation and bloating.  Additional symptoms and signs include non-specific rashes, breathing difficulties, muscle and joint aches, bladder problems, fatigue and flu-like symptoms, irritability, anxiety, depression, malaise, inability to concentrate, stupor (“brain fog”), hypotension, sleepiness, insomnia, mania, tremor and even paraesthesia.  These symptoms are attributed to a chronic prolonged and low dose environmental chemical exposure.

Overlap has been proposed with other environment-linked conditions such as Sick-building syndrome (SBS), food intolerance syndrome (FIS) and even Gulf War Illness (GWI).  It is postulated that trigger chemicals include formaldehyde found in furnishings and plastics, ink in newsprint and printers, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in cleaning materials, Freon in poorly ventilated buildings, sulphites, pesticides and other chemicals in wine and processed food products.  Those affected may also be prone to chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome, connective tissue disorders after silicone breast implants, reactive hypoglycaemia, drug-induced hepatitis, reactions related to living near toxic waste dumps and electromagnetism from power lines, dental amalgam disease and reactions to the petrol additive MTBE (methyl-tert-butyl ether).

Figure 1: Idiopathic Environmental Intolerance (IEI) diagnostic criteria:

  1. Symptoms recur and are reproducible
  2. The condition is chronic
  3. Low levels of exposure (lower than previously or commonly tolerated) result in manifestations of the syndrome (i.e. increasing sensitivity occurs over time)
  4. The symptoms improve, or resolve when the triggering chemicals are removed from the environment
  5. Responses often occur to multiple unrelated chemicals
  6. Symptoms involve multiple-organs (runny nose, itchy eyes, headache, scratchy throat, nausea and/or diarrhoea, abdominal cramping, aching joints etc.)

Immunological mechanisms (mainly non-IgE) have been proposed but none have been satisfactorily proven.  Terr extensively reviewed the immune theories proposed by the clinical ecologists and found none could be substantiated [3].  Aetiological theories are usually based on empiric hypotheses drawn mostly from poor quality studies published in the fringe medical press.  These have failed to establish any convincing evidential link between ill-health and day-to-day low-level chemical exposure.

A genetic predisposition with heightened sensitivity and abnormal olfactory or “odorant” receptors has also been proposed but never confirmed in clinical studies. In studies where the chemical odour was masked or suppressed by menthol, there was no difference between the study and control group symptomatology.

Many physicians believe that the symptoms of IEI are psycho-physiological in nature and those affected are prone to panic responses which enhance their symptoms.  Binckley and Kutcher demonstrated that individuals with self-identified chemical sensitivities responded with typical panic attacks when challenged with intravenous lactate (in a similar manner to individuals with underlying panic disorders) [4]. In Lenzoffs study, all the MCS patients who responded to a challenge with their trigger substances developed symptoms and signs of acute anxiety with hyperventilation and a rapid fall in PCO2, while their lung function remained normal [5].

In addition, IEI prone individuals appear to have a heightened olfactory awareness (hyperosmia) and a profound odour aversion (cacosmia) to otherwise harmless volatile organic compounds found in many household products, aerosols and even from trees. A recent systematic review of provocation studies for Multiple Chemical Sensitivities by Das-Munshi, Rubin and Wessely drew negative conclusions. Thirty seven provocation studies testing 784 persons reporting MCS and 547 controls were assessed in their meta-analysis [6].  Blinding was found to be inadequate in many studies, as most did not conceal the implicated chemical’s odour from their subjects. Only 3 studies used olfactory masking agents and in these none found associations between provocations and response. They concluded that persons with MCS/IEI do react to chemical challenges if they can smell the chemical but do not react when the odour is masked.  In one study participants were less likely to react to an odour described as “natural extracts with relaxing effects” (positive bias) as opposed to another described as “industrial solvents” (negative bias).  Thus suggesting their response was not to the chemical itself, but rather related to their “expectations and prior beliefs”.

Psychological conditioning has been proposed as the underlying abnormality in IEI, but is complicated by a high incidence of pre-morbid psychological trauma (including childhood physical and sexual abuse).  This may lead to profound long-term effects on mood and affect, cognitive processing, hypervigilence and entrenched beliefs of victimisation [7].   It is possible for patients with IEI to react to an olfactory sensation by amplifying the perceived effects into a full-blown panic attack and even trigger off underlying Idiopathic Anaphylaxis.

In the final analysis, after many years of investigation, there appears to be no convincing evidence in the medical literature for the existence of multiple chemical sensitivities or Idiopathic Environmental Intolerance.  The underlying cause for the IEI symptom complex is unlikely to be a direct reaction to everyday chemicals, but rather a masked stress disorder with heightened olfactory awareness (hyperosmia) and associated behavioural conditioning.

References:

  1. Cullen MR. The worker with multiple chemical sensitivities: an overview. Occup Med State Art Rev 1987;2:655-62
  2. Multiple chemical sensitivity: a 1999 consensus. Arch Environ Health 1999;54:147-9
  3. Terr AL. Unconventional theories and unproven methods of allergy. In: Middleton E, Reed CE, Ellis EF, Adkinson NF, Yunginger JW,  Busse WW editors. Allergy: principles and practice. 4th ed. St Louis: Mosby, 1993; 2: 1767-93
  4. Binckley K, Kutcher S. Panic response to sodium lactate infusion in patients with multiple chemical sensitivity syndrome J Allergy Clin Immunol 1997; 99:570-5
  5. Lenznoff A. Provocation challenges in patients with multiple chemical sensitivity. J Allergy Clin Immunology 1997;99:438-42
  6. Das-Munshi J, Rubin GJ, Wessely S. Multiple chemical sensitivities: A systematic review of provocation studies. J Allergy Clin Immunol; 2006; 118.6:1257-1264
  7. Staudenmayer H Multiple chemical sensitivities or Idiopathic environmentl intolerances: Psychophysiologic foundation of knowledge for a psychogenic explanation. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1997;99:434-7
Copyright Dr Adrian Morris Written 2008 & Reviewed June 2012
Advertisements

3 Comments

  1. Dear Dr. Morris,
    I read the above with interest and have long wondered if there is an endocrinological /or immunological connection to hyperosmia. Additionally, after reading the above data I am unclear as to the exact mechanism that produces genuine respiratory wheezing (which cannot be rehearsed) and described dyspnea for those who experience hyperosmia. I am curious to know if any research has been conducted along these lines?

    Hyperosmia in the first trimester of pregnancy is not uncommon,nor is it uncommon in some instances during the onset of migraine in chronic sufferers. Thus in my most humble observations,it would seem that a solely psychological etiology is unlikely.

  2. When my daughter had 2 metal dental spacers put in her mouth at age 4. She began having as she said worm like sensations in her stomach. Unfortunately she was also sexually abused at this time. As the years followed she constantly suffered from hallucinations, intestinal issues, sore throat, labored breathing , rashes, hives and headaches. Looking through her medical and dental records they coincide for almost every symptom. Especially fluoride treatments . Under psychiatric care they tried several medicines that only made her hallucinations worse. When my daughter suffered a Lisfranc injury and orthopedic plate was used. She would suffer from nerve pain and weird tremors and excruciating stiffness. It was confirm she was allergic to compounds that coat hardware that is used in the body. I am searching for dental fillings to back in her mouth. The fillings she had would cause blisters and she spit blood and taste like metal. When we remove the orthopedic plate her tremors in her limbs would stop by 90%. Despite everything we have done her brain is now swelling. It now has come to my attention the possibility of her being allergic to medicine. She is bedridden with full body neuropathy pain with no pills to help stop it. Her story is very long and painful. A lot of doctors did not understand at first wanting to say PTSD. Until only a small allergy test was done. I was so elated to find this article. I was wondering if you could help direct us for correct doctors? We have been to John Hopkins, Duke, CHKD and Richmond. I was flabbergasted after I had gone to all these places to understand bronopol and being explained it was just dermatitis. And dermatologist says none of this would upset her stomach the way it is. They were also injecting her with gadolinium sold under the trademark name bronopol, and so many times befor and after these appointments. Now that the brain has began swelling and the nerve pain spread throughout her body throughout the year. The word Idiopathic comes up a lot in her diagnosis. I noticed it is used throughout these articles. I was wondering if there was anything you could possibly do to please help? After two CRPS to the right foot it then sat in the left flank. And that’s when myself as a concerned mother knowing my extremely bright daughter was not lying or crazy my research began. I am able to pinpoint how her allergies have constantly been put in her body especially through cleaning agents being airborne along with others. I have her being a valuated to be put in the Harvard undiagnosed program. Yet medical does not seem to look at dental and it is a major part of her issue. Thank you and extremely tired and heartbroken mother Melissa Bangs

    1. Hi Missy,

      Thank you so much for sharing your daughter’s experiences.

      It is so important that we share our stories in order to help each other.

      I started this project as a small blog, just as resource for myself to keep track of underlying medical conditions and substances that are known to induce psychosis/mania and can result in a misdiagnosis of mental illness.

      The more information I added, the more hits it was getting, so I moved it to a wordpress free blog.

      I am not a medical professional. My goal as a mental health advocate is to support a unified advocacy agenda that will advance best practice standards of assessment and treatment.

      Below is a link to a narrative I wrote that was published in the Journal of Participatory Medicine that explains my own circumstances.

      I am originally from Syracuse, NY and was blessed to find a local medical doctor who was using a Functional Medicine/Orthomolecular approach.

      His name is Dr. Charles Gant and at the time I became a patient of his, intravenous Chelation therapy was available.

      http://charlesgantmd.com/about/

      I received great benefits from the Chelation treatments. As the lead levels came down, the symptoms subsided.

      You are on the right track. Keep searching for answers.

      What helped me a lot was going to the local medical library. The librarians were extremely helpful in finding information and getting me started on how to find more.

      Have you ever seen the movie Lorenzo’s Oil?

      It is very inspirational and one I think every parent should see.

      If you have any questions, please feel free to email me at mangicaro33@gmail.com

      You and your daughter will be in my thoughts and prayers.
      Maria

      https://participatorymedicine.org/journal/perspective/narratives/2011/03/28/psychosis-possibly-linked-to-an-occupational-disease-an-e-patient%E2%80%99s-participatory-approach-to-consideration-of-etiologic-factors/

      http://charlesgantmd.com/about/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s